Kristy Swanson
Buffy Summers

Donald Sutherland
Merrick Jamison-Smythe

Paul Reubens
Amilyn

Rutger Hauer
Lothos

Luke Perry
Oliver Pike

Hilary Swank
Kimberly Hannah

Michele Abrams
Jennifer

David Arquette
Benny

Natasha Gregson Wagner
Cassandra

Thomas Jane
Zeph

Ricki Lake
Charlotte

Stephen Root
Gary Murray

Sasha Jenson
Grueller

Candy Clark
Buffy's Mom

Paris Vaughan
Nicole 'Nicki'

Randall Batinkoff
Jeffrey

Andrew Lowery
Andy

Mark DeCarlo
Coach

James Paradise
Buffy's Dad

David Sherrill
Knight

Paul M. Lane
Robert Berman

Toby Holguin
Vampire Fan

Eurlyne Epper
Graveyard Woman

Michael Kopelow
Student

Ricky Dean Logan
Bloody Student

Amanda Anka
Vampire

Chino Binamo
Vampire

Al Goto
Vampire

Kim Robert Koscki
Vampire

Clint Lilley
Vampire

Chi Muoi Lo
Vampire

David Rowden
Vampire

Ben Scott
Vampire

Sharon Schaffer
Vampire

Ben Affleck
Basketball Player #10 (uncredited)

Alexis Arquette
Vampire DJ (uncredited)

Slash
DJ (uncredited)

Liz Smith
Self – Reporter

Eric DaRe
Biker (uncredited)

Seth Green
Vampire (uncredited)