Eva Victor
Agnes Ward

Naomi Ackie
Lydie

Louis Cancelmi
Preston Decker

Kelly McCormack
Natasha

Lucas Hedges
Gavin

John Carroll Lynch
Pete

Hettienne Park
Eleanor Winston

Cody Reiss
Devin

Jordan Mendoza
Logan

Anabel Graetz
Professor Wilkinson

Jonathan Myles
The Man She Thought Was Decker

Danny Diaz
Student

Liz Bishop
Elizabeth

David J. Curtis
Judge

Priscilla Manning
Andrea Fuller

Jesse Gabbard
Hector Woguard

Lucien Spelman
Kevin Faber

Celeste Oliva
Sophie

Conor Sweeney
Jeremy

Tierre Diaz
Juror (uncredited)

Jim Powers
Shopper (uncredited)