David Howard Thornton
Steamboat Willie

Jesse Kove
Lieutenant Diaz

Jesse Posey
Pete

Charles Edwin Powell
Borough President Molinari

Amy Schumacher
Amber

Jarlath Conroy
Barry

Allison Pittel
Selena

Jarod Lindsey
Moses

Rumi C. Jean-Louis
Matteo

Anthony E. Williams
Officer Martinez

Tyler Posey
Radio Operator Mike

Jared Johnston
Neil

Brian Quinn
Mitch McEverly

Kailey Hyman
Cindi

Brian Scolaro
Captain Clark

Sarah Kopkin
Ilsa Arindel

Tommy Bechtold
TJ

Joe DeRosa
Paul Sanguino

Ken Maharaj
Albert

Michael Leavy
Deckhand Bert Brunswick

Poonam Basu
Jazzy

Steven Della Salla
Charlie DeLorenzo

Jason Lockhart
Cyclist Peter

Allyson Sereboff
Aubrey

Rachel Victoria Moore
Jamie

Gilbrando Acevedo
The Shirtless Cowboy

Peter Romano
Officer Chris

Tammi Cubilette
Liz