Genevieve Hannelius
Charity (voice)

Marlowe Peyton
Jingle (voice)

Aidan Gemme
Noble (voice)

Cheryl Ladd
Mrs. Claus

Danny Woodburn
Eli

Richard Kind
Eddy the Elf Dog (voice)

Kaitlyn Maher
Sarah Reynolds

George Newbern
Thomas Reynolds

Trevor Wright
Baxter (voice)

Obba Babatundé
Mayor Denny

Ali Hillis
Agnes Bright

Jennifer Elise Cox
Blue Bright

Audrey Wasilewski
Dorothy Bright

Bill Chott
Mr. Holman

Paul Rae
Jeb Gibson

Brian T. Finney
Sheriff Andy

Ted Rooney
Mr. Miller

Diedrich Bader
Comet (voice)

Chris Coppola
Dancer (voice)

Josh Flitter
Brutus (voice)

Bryce Clyde Jenkins
Emmett

Pat Finn
Santa Claus

Tom Everett Scott
Santa Paws (voice)

Bonnie Somerville
Mrs. Paws (voice)

Jay Brazeau
Judge

Joey Bothwell
Mildred

Nic Novicki
Ellis

Michael Teigen
Mr. Kent