Hurd Hatfield
Dorian Gray

George Sanders
Lord Henry Wotton

Donna Reed
Gladys Hallward

Angela Lansbury
Sibyl Vane

Peter Lawford
David Stone

Lowell Gilmore
Basil Hallward

Richard Fraser
James Vane

Douglas Walton
Allen Campbell

Morton Lowry
Adrian Singleton

Miles Mander
Sir Robert Bentley

Lydia Bilbrook
Mrs. Vane

Mary Forbes
Lady Agatha

Robert Greig
Sir Thomas

Moyna MacGill
Duchess

Billy Bevan
Malvolio Jones

Lilian Bond
Kate

John George
Hunchback (uncredited)

William H. O'Brien
Footman (uncredited)

Frank O'Connor
Selby Estate Butler (uncredited)

Cedric Hardwicke
Narrator (voice)