Tyrone Power
Don Diego Vega, aka Zorro

Linda Darnell
Lolita Quintero

Basil Rathbone
Captain Esteban Pasquale

Gale Sondergaard
Inez Quintero

Eugene Pallette
Friar Felipe

J. Edward Bromberg
Don Luis B. Quintero

Montagu Love
Don Alejandro Vega

Janet Beecher
Senora Isabella Vega

George Regas
Sergeant Gonzales

Chris-Pin Martin
Turnkey

Robert Lowery
Rodrigo

Belle Mitchell
Maria

John Bleifer
Pedro

Frank Puglia
Proprietor

Pedro de Cordoba
Don Miguel

Guy D'Ennery
Don Jose

Eugene Borden
Officer of the Day (uncredited)

Stanley Andrews
Commanding Officer (uncredited)

Fortunio Bonanova
Sentry (uncredited)

Ralph Byrd
Student / Officer (uncredited)

Robert Conway
(uncredited)

Gino Corrado
Caballero (uncredited)

Jean Del Val
Sentry (uncredited)

William Edmunds
Peón Selling Cocks (uncredited)

Victor Kilian
Boatman (uncredited)

Fred Malatesta
Sentry (uncredited)

Francisco Moreno
Peon (uncredited)

Ted North
(uncredited)

Charles Stevens
José (uncredited)

Rafael Alcayde
Diego's Manservant (uncredited)

Paul Sutton
Morales (uncredited)

Harry Worth
Caballero (uncredited)

Frank Yaconelli
Don Alejandro's Servant (uncredited)