Anna Faris
Kate Sullivan

Eugenio Derbez
Leonardo Montenegro

Eva Longoria
Theresa

John Hannah
Colin

Swoosie Kurtz
Grace

Mel Rodriguez
Bobby

Josh Segarra
Jason

Hannah Nordberg
Emily Sullivan

Alyvia Alyn Lind
Olivia Sullivan

Payton Lepinski
Molly Sullivan

Fernando Luján
Papi

Cecilia Suárez
Magdalena

Mariana Treviño
Sofia

Jesús Ochoa
Vito

Omar Chaparro
Burro

Adrián Uribe
Burrito

Edgar Vivar
Gastroenterologist

Per Graffman
Captain

Nils Hognestad
First Mate

Thomas Nicholson
Crew Member

Javier Lacroix
Carlos - Cook

Edwin Perez
Dishwasher

Garry Chalk
Dr. Fletcher

Morgan Brayton
Nurse

Darla Fay
Receptionist

Toby Hargrave
Local Boat Mechanic

Elizabeth Bowen
Boat Mechanic's Wife

Eric Keenleyside
Elk Cove Sheriff

Emily Maddison
Amanda

Cynthia Mendez
Lucia

Angie Larocque
Genevieve

Michael Karl Richards
Rich Client

Linda Pollard
Female Mikado Performer

David Mathews
Male Mikado Performer

Lia Farrelly-Hodge
Jet Skier #1

Celeste Ziegler
Jet Skier #2

Stephi Chin-Salvo
Jet Skier #3

Tara Erica Moore
Pretty Girl

Lee Shan Gibson
Cop

Guy Christie
Flag Football Parent

Ron Bottitta
Soccer Commentator (voice) (uncredited)