Tom Holland
Arvin Russell

Robert Pattinson
Reverend Preston Teagardin

Bill Skarsgård
Willard Russell

Riley Keough
Sandy Henderson

Jason Clarke
Carl Henderson

Sebastian Stan
Deputy Lee Bodecker

Haley Bennett
Charlotte Russell

Harry Melling
Roy Laferty

Eliza Scanlen
Lenora Laferty

Mia Wasikowska
Helen Hatton

Douglas Hodge
Leroy Brown

Kristin Griffith
Emma

Pokey LaFarge
Theodore

Donald Ray Pollock
Narrator (voice)

Banks Repeta
Arvin At 9

David Atkinson
Earskell

Gregory Kelly
BoBo McDaniels

David Maldonado
Henry Dunlap

Mark Jeffrey Miller
Hank

Wes Robinson
Bus Driver

Todd Barnett
Wooden Spoon Manager

Michael Harding
Reverend Albert Sykes

Lucy Faust
Cynthia Teagardin

Abby Glover
Pamela Sue Reaster

Kelly Lind
Church Member #1

Adam Fristoe
Priest

Morganna Bridgers
Florence

Karson Kern
Social Worker

Ivan Hoey Jr.
Orville Buckman

Zack Shires
Gene Dinwoodie

Drew Starkey
Tommy Matson

Caleb J. Thaggard
Butcher

Given Sharp
Susie Cox

Cory Scott Allen
Sheriff Thompson

Emma Coulter
Juanita

Jason Collett
Gary Matthew Bryson

Eric Mendenhall
Deputy Howser

Michael H. Cole
Doctor

Daniel James Vaughn
Dispatcher

Edward Hall
Skinned Soldier

Jeff McCarthy
Evangelist

Santino Fontana
AM Radio DJ

John Rue
Newscaster

Phillip DeVona
Calvin Claytor (uncredited)

Kevin Waterman
Arresting Police Officer (uncredited)

Sarah Hamff
Beth Ann Reaster (uncredited)

James H. Keating
Meat Processor (uncredited)

Scott Rapp
Teacher (uncredited)

Kyle Sawyer
Shop Patron (uncredited)

Emily Towles
1965 High School Student (uncredited)

Leslie Sides
Church Goer (uncredited)

Jason Charles Hill
Local Pool Player (uncredited)