Jennifer Aniston
Linda

Paul Rudd
George

Justin Theroux
Seth

Malin Åkerman
Eva

Kathryn Hahn
Karen

Lauren Ambrose
Almond

Alan Alda
Carvin

Joe Lo Truglio
Wayne Davidson

Ken Marino
Rick Gergenblatt

Jordan Peele
Rodney Wilson

Kerri Kenney
Kathy

Michaela Watkins
Marissa

Patricia French
Beverly

Jessica St. Clair
Deena Schuster

Todd Barry
Sherm

Linda Lavin
Shari

David Wain
Himself

Michael Showalter
Himself

Michael Ian Black
Himself

Zandy Hartig
Marcy

Keegan-Michael Key
Marcy’s Flunkie

Mather Zickel
Jim Stansel

Ray Liotta
Himself

Peter Salett
Manfreddie

Juan Piedrahita
Paco

Martin Thompson
Dale

Ian Patrick
Grisham

John D'Leo
Tanner

Nina Hellman
Protester

Richard Allan Jones
Jerry Beaver

Juana Samayoa
Stephanie Davis

Trisha Paytas
Davidson's Wife (uncredited)

Ron Raines
Shari's Partner (uncredited)

Rosemary Howard
Manhattan Pedestrian (uncredited)

Nina Nayebi
Woman at Casino Table (uncredited)

Katherine Neslund
Concerned Citizen (uncredited)

Joel Rogers
Minivan Freeway Driver (uncredited)