Andrew Garfield
Jonathan Larson

Alexandra Shipp
Susan Wilson

Robin de Jesús
Michael

Michaela Jaé Rodriguez
Carolyn

Ben Levi Ross
Freddy

Jonathan Marc Sherman
Ira Weitzman

Vanessa Hudgens
Karessa Johnson

Joshua Henry
Roger Bart

Bradley Whitford
Stephen Sondheim

Judith Light
Rosa Stevens

Laura Benanti
Judy

Danielle Ferland
Kim

Micaela Diamond
Peggy

Utkarsh Ambudkar
Todd

Gizel Jiménez
Cristin

Kate Rockwell
Lauren

Joel Perez
Lincoln

Judy Kuhn
Nan

Danny Burstein
Al

Lauren Marcus
Donna

Richard Kind
Walter Bloom

Tariq Trotter
H.A.W.K. Smooth

Kenita R. Miller
Sextet Actor #2

Eddy Lee
Sextet Actor #3

Ryan Vasquez
Scott

Joanna Adler
Molly

Sheila Tapia
Nurse

Ricardo Zayas
Hospital Man #1

Travis Patton
Hospital Man #2

Christopher Jackson
TTB Concert Attendee

Jelani Alladin
David

Luis A. Miranda Jr.
Building Concierge

Chuck Cooper
"Sunday" Legend #1

André De Shields
"Sunday" Legend #2

Renée Elise Goldsberry
"Sunday" Legend #3

Joel Grey
"Sunday" Legend #4

Wilson Jermaine Heredia
"Sunday" Legend #5

Beth Malone
"Sunday" Legend #6

Howard McGillin
"Sunday" Legend #7

Brian Stokes Mitchell
"Sunday" Legend #8

Bebe Neuwirth
"Sunday" Legend #9

Adam Pascal
"Sunday" Legend #10

Bernadette Peters
"Sunday" Legend #11

Phylicia Rashād
"Sunday" Legend #12

Chita Rivera
"Sunday" Legend #13

Daphne Rubin-Vega
"Sunday" Legend #14

Phillipa Soo
"Sunday" Legend #15

Chad Beguelin
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Nick Blaemire
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Eli Bolin
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Jason Robert Brown
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Eisa Davis
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Amanda Green
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Quiara Alegría Hudes
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Joe Iconis
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Tom Kitt
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Alex Lacamoire
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Steven Levenson
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Jaime Lozano
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Dave Malloy
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Matthew McCollum
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Grace McLean
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Helen Park
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Stephen Schwartz
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Marc Shaiman
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Matthew Sklar
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Georgia Stitt
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Shaina Taub
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Jeanine Tesori
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Stephen Trask
Aspiring Composers and Lyricists

Derrick Delgado
Young Michael

Mason Versaw
Teenage Jon

Roger Bart
Featured Diner #2

Gaby Diaz
Susan Company Dancer #7

Ilia Jessica Castro
"PLAY GAME" Dancer #1

Lane Napper
Bookstore Dancer #1

Christopher Grant
"SUNDAY" Busboy Dancer #1

Elizabeth Chestang
Lobby Dancer #1

Ehizoje Azeke
Lobby Dancer #7

Adriel Flete
HS West Side Dancer #3

Lin-Manuel Miranda
Diner Manager (uncredited)

Stephen Sondheim
Stephen Sondheim (voice on phone) (uncredited)

Ken Holmes
YMCA Poolgoer (uncredited)

Jonathan Larson
Self (archive footage) (uncredited)