Billy Eichner
Bobby

Luke Macfarlane
Aaron

Guy Branum
Henry

Miss Lawrence
Wanda

Ts Madison
Angela

Dot-Marie Jones
Cherry

Jim Rash
Robert

Eve Lindley
Tamara

Monica Raymund
Tina

Guillermo Díaz
Edgar

Jai Rodriguez
Jason

Amanda Bearse
Anne

Debra Messing
Debra Messing

Peter Y. Kim
Peter

Justin Covington
Paul

Symone
Marty

Ryan Faucett
Josh

Becca Blackwell
Lucas

D'Lo
Tom

Harvey Fierstein
Louis

Bowen Yang
Lawrence Grape

Derrick Delgado
Brian

George Dvorsky
Bruce

Jamyl Dobson
Joel

Brock Ciarlelli
Steve

Kenan Thompson
James Baldwin

Amy Schumer
Eleanor Roosevelt

Jillian Gottlieb
Samantha

Rick Crom
Grape's Neighbor

Everett Quinton
Melvin Funk

Julia Scotti
Straight Older Woman

Nanie Méndez
Party Guest

William Popp
Pride Awards Football Player

Aidan Wharton
Football Player

Kristin Chenoweth
Kristin Chenoweth

Shannon O'Neill
Paula

Matthew Wilkas
Handsome Grindr Guy

Ben Stiller
Ben Stiller (uncredited)

Seth Meyers
Harvey Milk (uncredited)

Anthony DeVito
Straight Liberal Dad (uncredited)

Joanne Lamstein
Straight Liberal Mom (uncredited)