Jason Sudeikis
Eric Keppler

Leslie Bibb
Kelly

Lindsay Sloane
Laura

Lake Bell
Alison Lobel

Michelle Borth
Sue Plummer

Nick Kroll
Adam Richman

Tyler Labine
Mike McCrudden

Angela Sarafyan
Willow Talbot

Martin Starr
Doug Duquez

Rhys Coiro
Marcus

Will Forte
Glenn

Michael Harding
Mr. Weber

David Koechner
Vic George

Andrea Powell
Female Cop

DeeDee Rescher
Ellen

Lucy Punch
Kate

Jan Harrelson
Emcee / DJ

Bob Hungerford
Farmer

Peter Huyck
Pete

Lin Shaye
Dody

Jon Stafford
Fred

Barbara Weetman
Mrs. Weber

Darrell Barr
Sex Swing Guy (uncredited)

Don Johnson
Jerry Keppler (uncredited)