Kristen Wiig
Imogene

Annette Bening
Zelda

Matt Dillon
George

Darren Criss
Lee

Christopher Fitzgerald
Ralph

June Diane Raphael
Dara

Natasha Lyonne
Allyson

Bob Balaban
Maxwell

Sydney Lucas
Little Imogene

Jimmy Palumbo
Doorman Joe

Michelle Morgan
Georgina

Mickey Sumner
Hannah

Brian Petsos
Peter Van Woodsen

Murray Bartlett
James Whitney

Melissa Navia
Assistant

Michelle Hurd
Libby

Cynthia Nixon
Cynthia Nixon

Reed Birney
Dr. Chalmers

Manny Siverio
Gino

Nnamdi Nwosa
Bruce

Akira Takayama
Casino Gambler

Helmar Augustus Cooper
Delancey Security Guard

Tandy Cronyn
Hermione

Nate Corddry
Larry Feinstein

Mike Keller
NJ Cop / T-Rex Rinaldi

Henriette Mantel
Female Police Officer

Jonny Orsini
Nick

Julia Macchio
Lucy

Emma Myles
Hippie Girl

Padma Lakshmi
Padma Lakshmi

Frank Pando
NYPD Police Officer #1

Daniella van Graas
Cecille

Ronald Guttman
Armando

Julia Stiles
Stage Imogene

Andrea Martin
Stage Zelda

Graeme Malcolm
Culture Vulture

Whit Stillman
Whit Stillman

Patricia Kalember
Virginia

Marceline Hugot
Librarian

Ilana Levine
Teacher