Anna Kendrick
Sheryl

Daniel Zovatto
Rodney

Tony Hale
Ed

Nicolette Robinson
Laura

Autumn Best
Amy

Pete Holmes
Terry

Kathryn Gallagher
Charlie

Kelley Jakle
Sarah

Matt Visser
Bachelor #1

Jedidiah Goodacre
Bachelor #2

Rob Morton
Custodian (George Elliot)

Dylan Schmid
Mario

Karen Holness
Gretchen

Denalda Williams
Marilyn

Jessie Fraser
Lisa

Matty Finochio
Casting Director

Geoff Gustafson
Casting Director

Max Lloyd-Jones
Ken

Andy Thompson
Bob

Nancy Kerr
Diane

James Yi
Joe

Jessica Chaffin
Helen

Matthew Kevin Anderson
Mark

Taylor Hastings
Melanie

David Beairsto
Rodney's Boss

Darcy Laurie
Marty

Marc Gaudet
Head Mover

Bonnie Hay
Bartender

Michael Adamthwaite
Dating Game Director

Jacob Woike
Dating Game 1st Assistant Director

Jason Simpson
Dating Game Announcer

Hannah Henney
Bachelorette (Playback)

Tighe Gill
Bachelor (Playback)

Michael Jonsson
Booth Security Guard (Harold)

Thomas Strumpski
Laundromat Owner

John Herkenrath
Detective

Jeremy Radin
Detective