Mel Gibson
Gene Carruthers

Mason Thames
Noah Reed

Julian Lerner
Eugene Wexler

Abigail James Witherspoon
Sammy Devers

Noah Cottrell
Ben Driskel

Nora Zehetner
Abby Reed

Lorraine Bracco
Miss Halverson

Emma Fasano
Lilly Reed

Spencer Fitzgerald
Ronnie Harlow

Patrick Renna
Umpire

Ashley Rae Trisler
Witch

Gavin Bedell
Kevin Lampkey

Gary Weeks
Chief Hartley

Bobbi Baker
Hannah Driskel

Kelly Collins Lintz
Deb Harlow

Nico Tirozzi
Little Boy / Carruthers' Son

Lilah Pate
Ellie Evans

Kevin James
Edgar Palmer

Barbara Goodson
The Witch (voice)

Robert Fortunato
Police Officer (uncredited)

Art Newkirk
Dad in Theater (uncredited)

David Pascua
Police Officer