Elizabeth Banks
Lindsay

H. Jon Benjamin
Mitch / Can of Vegetables (voice)

Michael Ian Black
McKinley / George H.W. Bush

Janeane Garofalo
Beth

Nina Hellman
Nancy

Ken Marino
Victor Pulak

A.D. Miles
Gary

Marguerite Moreau
Katie

Zak Orth
J.J.

Amy Poehler
Susie

Paul Rudd
Andy

Marisa Ryan
Abby

Michael Showalter
Coop / Ronald Reagan

Lake Bell
Donna

Sarah Burns
Claire

Josh Charles
Blake

Mark Feuerstein
Mark

Samm Levine
Arty

Alyssa Milano
Renata Murphy

Adam Scott
Ben

Eric Nenninger
Warner

Rich Sommer
Graham

David Wain
Yaron / Bill Clinton