Colin Farrell
Peter Lake

Jessica Brown Findlay
Beverly Penn

Russell Crowe
Pearly Soames

William Hurt
Isaac Penn

Jennifer Connelly
Virginia Gamely

Will Smith
Judge

Eva Marie Saint
Willa (Adult)

Graham Greene
Humpstone John

Matt Bomer
Young Man

Kevin Durand
Cesar Tan

Kevin Corrigan
Romeo Tan

Lucy Griffiths
Mrs. Lake

Finn Wittrock
Gabriel

Michael Crane
Ellis Isle Doctor

Brian Hutchison
Ellis Isle Official

Alan Doyle
Dingy Worthington

Jon Patrick Walker
Optometrist

Maurice Jones
Cecil Mature

Mckayla Twiggs
Young Willa

Matthew R. Staley
Oyster Boy

Scott Grimes
Carriage Driver

Brenda Wehle
Governess

Tom Morrissey
Butler

Joshua Henry
Gravesman

Ripley Sobo
Abby

Maggie Geha
Girl in Bed

Caitlin Dulany
Librarian

Norm Lewis
Custodian

Harriett D. Foy
Receptionist

Rob Campbell
Gwathmi

Scott Dillin
Grand Central Short Tail

Luis Augusto Figueroa
Ballroom Dancer

April Grace
Dr. Elizabeth Lee