James Stewart
Marshal Guthrie McCabe

Richard Widmark
First Lt. Jim Gary

Shirley Jones
Marty Purcell

Linda Cristal
Elena de la Madriaga

Andy Devine
Sgt. Darius P. Posey

John McIntire
Major Frazer

Paul Birch
Judge Edward Purcell

Willis Bouchey
Mr. Harry J. Wringle

Henry Brandon
Chief Quanah Parker

Harry Carey, Jr.
Ortho Clegg

Olive Carey
Mrs. Abby Frazer

Ken Curtis
Greeley Clegg

Anna Lee
Mrs. Malaprop

Jeanette Nolan
Mrs. Mary McCandless

John Qualen
Ole Knudsen

Ford Rainey
Rev. Henry Clegg

Woody Strode
Stone Calf

O.Z. Whitehead
Lt. Whitehead

Chuck Roberson
Comanche

Gertrude Astor
Mrs. Wringle (uncredited)

Bill Borzage
Settler (uncredited)

Regina Carrol
Wakanana (uncredited)

Ruth Clifford
Woman (uncredited)

Rian Garrick
Lieutenant Upton (uncredited)

Big John Hamilton
Settler (uncredited)

Chuck Hayward
Trooper (uncredited)

William Henry
Gambler (uncredited)

Robert Kenneally
Officer (uncredited)

Jack Kenny
Settler (uncredited)

James Kirkwood
Officer (uncredited)

Cliff Lyons
William McCandless (uncredited)

Mae Marsh
Hanna Clegg (uncredited)

Boyd 'Red' Morgan
Gambler (uncredited)

Jack Pennick
Sergeant (uncredited)

Leoda Richards
Party Guest (uncredited)

Chuck Roberson
Comanche (uncredited)