Catherine Keener
Kate

Amanda Peet
Mary

Oliver Platt
Alex

Rebecca Hall
Rebecca

Ann Morgan Guilbert
Andra

Lois Smith
Mrs. Portman

Sarah Steele
Abby

Thomas Ian Nicholas
Eugene

Elizabeth Keener
Cathy

Elise Ivy
Marissa

Josh Pais
Adam

Griffin Frazen
Shopper

Reggie Austin
Shopper

Scott Cohen
Dr. Lerner

Paul Sparks
Blind Date

Amy Wright
Erin

Arthur French
Man Waiting for a Table

Neal Lerner
Leaf Man

Maddie Corman
Shopper

Alice Spivak
Shopper

Emma Myles
Salesgirl

Rebecca Budig
Big Back

Romy Rosemont
Carrie-Ann

Kathleen Doyle
Anita

Sarah Vowell
Shopper

Jason Mantzoukas
Shopper

Kevin Corrigan
Don

Elizabeth Berridge
Elyse

Erica Fae
Shopper

Michael Panes
Shopper

Charles Techman
Homeless Man

Portia
Mrs. Melnick