Paul Douglas
Guffy McGovern

Janet Leigh
Jennifer Paige

Keenan Wynn
Fred Bayles

Donna Corcoran
Bridget White

Lewis Stone
Arnold P. Hapgood

Spring Byington
Sister Edwitha

Bruce Bennett
Saul Hellman

Marvin Kaplan
Timothy Durney

Ellen Corby
Sister Veronica

Jeff Richards
Dave Rothberg

John Gallaudet
Reynolds

King Donovan
McGee

Don Haggerty
Rube Ronson

Fred Graham
Chunk

John McKee
Bill Baxter

Barbara Billingsley
Hat Check Girl (uncredited)

Bing Crosby
Bing Crosby (uncredited)

Joe DiMaggio
Joe DiMaggio (uncredited)

Pat Flaherty
Boston Braves Manager (uncredited)

Douglas Fowley
Cab Driver (uncredited)

Peter Graves
Radio Announcer (uncredited)

Richard Hale
Dr. Blane (uncredited)

Bill Hickman
Reporter #1 (uncredited)

Tor Johnson
Wrestler on TV (uncredited)

Dick Simmons
Larry Moss (uncredited)

James Whitmore
Angel (voice) (uncredited)

Harold Miller
Baseball Fan (uncredited)

Bill Walker
Dining Car Waiter

Harry Hayden
Doctor