Tom Guiry
Scotty Smalls

Mike Vitar
Benjamin Franklin Rodriguez

Patrick Renna
Hamilton 'Ham' Porter

Chauncey Leopardi
Michael 'Squints' Palledorous

Marty York
Alan 'Yeah-Yeah' McClennan

Brandon Quintin Adams
Kenny DeNunez

Grant Gelt
Bertram Grover Weeks

James Earl Jones
Mr. Mertle

Denis Leary
Bill

Karen Allen
Mom

Shane Obedzinski
Tommy 'Repeat' Timmons

Victor DiMattia
Timmy Timmons

Art LaFleur
The Babe

Marley Shelton
Wendy

Daniel Zacapa
Police Chief

Eddie Matthews
Thief

Keith Campbell
Thief

Wil Horneff
Phillips

Robert Apisa
Home Plate Umpire

Arliss Howard
Adult Scotty Smalls (uncredited)

David Mickey Evans
Narrator (voice / uncredited)